Re: how to generate a host/network unreachable

Robert Forsman (thoth@cis.ufl.edu)
Tue, 04 Jun 1996 15:54:21 EDT

jeffm@iglou.com (Jeff Mcadams) ,in message <m0uR1QL-000s8EC@iglou.com>, wrote:

> No, systems will do a ping-pong if the routes point to each
> other...happens all the time.

Right, ISP A is responsible for net d, but happens to not have a route for
it at the time, so bounces it through the default route to upstream provider
B who says, "net d clearly belongs to ISP A" and bounces it back.

> In general its not a problem since a
> network that isn't in use generally won't have people trying to use it.
> Are you having a problem with this?

three words: "dial up network". Specifically 207.100.1.32/27, housing
giza.purplefrog.com, among others. When I dial in from home, there's a
route. When I'm not dialed in, there's no route, and you'll bounce between
icix and lw.net for days.

> In general if you see the ping-pong thing, its a routing problem
> somewhere, but not a network that is delegated but not in use. :)

In specific, it is exactly a network that is delegated and not in use.